Sunday, November 23, 2008 | 8:44 a.m.

Wine Talk by Robert Whitley

Home > Lifestyle Columns > Wine Talk
Please contact your local newspaper editor if you want to read Wine Talk's column in your hometown paper.
Robert Whitley

Recently

  • Comfort Foods Call for Comfort Wines on Thanksgiving Day
    Right about now my e-mail inbox is overflowing with questions about which wine with which dish this Thanksgiving. Obviously ‘tis the season to worry about the things that are really important! From year to year, Thanksgiving to Thanksgiving, I am …

  • Readers Fume Over Alcohol Content
    Since my most recent lament over the alarming rise in the alcohol levels of highly rated wines, several readers have written to suggest I publish alcohol levels alongside wine reviews. I have given this idea serious consideration, but at this time I …

  • The Quality of a Wine Is in the Eye of the Beholder
    It has recently come to the attention of some very astute readers that wine critics often disagree. Imagine that! What raised a few eyebrows was the Wine Spectator's low-ball score on the 2005 Nickel & Nickel Stelling Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon.…

  • Australia Proves the Exception to the Rule
    In this highly charged political season, I feel the need to demonstrate that I, too, have a big tent. So no sooner had the ink dried on my screed about the motive for those big shouldered, powerful, high-alcohol California wines, I found myself in …

Whitley finally ready to whittle down

With my three big wine competitions - Monterey, San Diego and Critics Challenge - now squarely in my rear-view mirror for another season, I've been able to return to my regular tasting schedule. Not only have I whittled down the pile of samples that awaited me, I am pleased to report that I came across a number of superb wines.

Even better, they are wines from producers I've long admired for their tenacious embrace of quality.

There is a wine here, for example, from Merry Edwards. I first met Merry nearly two decades ago. She was pursuing pinot noir in the Russian River Valley with a passion, but she also had quite a good reputation for the cabs and chardonnays she made while the winemaker at Mount Eden Vineyards, in the Santa Cruz Mountains.

Merry's Pinots these days are some of the boldest and most age-worthy produced in California, and very much in the style of a premier cru or grand cru Burgundy, with plenty of tannin and earthy complexities. They aren't cheap, but few wines this good are.

I also took note of two lovely Napa Valley reds from Joseph Phelps, whose red meritage "Insignia" is perhaps America's finest red wine. I've known Joe since the early years and always marveled at his willingness to push the envelope despite the fact his wines were already being heaped with praise. Phelps has kept up with the times, which is evident in its polished 2005 syrah and cabernet sauvignon.

You don't have to shell out $200 or more for Insignia a taste of Phelps' greatness. You can spend far less and enjoy a bottle of what Joe likes to call "good old Napa Valley Cabernet." Amen to that.

And then there's Bonny Doon's Randall Grahm. He takes the prize for innovation and willful neglect of his personal financial health. I mean that in only the best way, for Grahm has been willing to walk out on a limb time and time in his career to make wines no one else finds fashionable. He affectionately calls them "ugly ducklings."

So today I commend to you two of Bonny Doon's Ca' del Solo whites, one made from the Spanish grape variety Albarino, and a dry muscat that knocked my socks off.

Great wines from fabulous producers dedicated to quality more than most. You deserve no less.

TASTING NOTES

Wines are rated on a 100-point scale. Wines are chosen for review because they represent outstanding quality or value.

Merry Edwards 2005 "Coopersmith" Pinot Noir, Russian River Valley ($54) - The purity of fruit. Ripe, rich raspberry and blueberry coupled with weight and richness in the mouth set this pinot apart. It's a blockbuster, showing remarkable depth and layered complexity that is usually only seen at this stage (meaning while the wine is so young) in the slightly sweeter pinots that push the envelope on the alcohol level. Yep, this is a powerful pinot, on the order of a grand cru Burgundy from a good vintage, with exceptional length and very, very good balance. Slightly grippy on the finish, indicating it is still several years away from its optimum moment. Rating: 94.

Joseph Phelps 2005 Syrah, Napa Valley ($45) - I just love the pure blueberry, blackberry core that goes to the doorstep of jamminess without crossing the threshold.
This vintage shows a fair amount of black pepper spice,and a smoked meat nuance as well. It has the weight and depth to tackle bold flavors from the kitchen and the structure to age out nicely over the next five to seven years. This isn't exactly a summer wine, lending itself I believe more to roasts and stews, but if you're thinking about an upscale barbecue and looking for a wine to pair with charred, earthy meats from the grill, stop looking. Rating: 91.

Joseph Phelps 2005 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley ($54) - Cabernet lovers will flip over the deep, rich nose of ripe cassis. This is pure Napa Valley Cabernet at its best. Still youthful and fresh on the palate, with good acidity and nicely integrated tannins, this wine has yet to lose its primary fruit and lengthen out, things that will come after a couple of years in the cellar. If you've grown weary of the heavy, sweet cabs pouring forth recently from the Napa Valley, take a trip back to the way things were when Napa cabernets were well-balanced and long-lived. Open a bottle of the '05 Phelps. Rating: 90.

Veramonte 2005 Primus, Chile ($21) - This wine has changed considerably since its inception, when the winery mistakenly thought it had Merlot planted in the cool Colchagua Valley. In reality the "Merlot" was Carmenere, which thrives in warmer climes, but delivers a thin, weedy wine when it doesn't get ripe enough. Over the past several years the plantings have been adjusted and now that really is Merlot that comprises 51 percent of this red Bodeaux-style blend. The '05 is well-balanced, with an herbal note that in fact might make you think its origins are rooted in Bordeaux, and there are wonderful red-fruited aromas and spice and a freshness and complexity that make this one of the finest values in the world at this price. Rating: 90.

Ca' del Solo 2007 Estate Albarino, Monterey County ($20) - It's been a long time coming, but domestic vintners have finally caught on to Albarino, the intriguing white grape of Galicia's Rias Baixas district, which hugs the coastline of northwest Spain. California's Central Coast, particularly the cooler inland valleys that run east-west to the Pacific, seem to provide a climate that is hospitable to Albarino. Ca' del Solo's 2007 vintage from its estate vineyard in Monterey County is one of this country's finest examples of Albarino to date, displaying fresh lime and scintillating minerality in a wine that is perhaps the quintessential accompaniment to freshly shucked oysters or steamed clams. Rating: 90.

Ca' del Solo 2007 Estate Muscat, Monterey County ($17) - The 'M' in Muscat must stand for misunderstood. Sort of makes me wonder why anyone this side of Italy's Piedmont region plants the grape. But Grahm loves grapes others consider "ugly ducklings." He knows the beauty of a well-balanced Moscato served with Mediterranean tapas on a warm summer night. Everyone's skittish around muscat, however, because they are deathly afraid it's going to be sticky sweet. And, by God, many of them are. So what? Get over it, or take a stab at one of those sweeter muscats with a light fruit-based dessert. But Grahm's Muscat has another purpose. It's dry and crisp, although the honeysuckle nose could fool you. But on the palate it's dry and fresh and cries out for food. Maybe some fried zucchini blossom stuffed with cheese; maybe something as simple as fresh porcini mushrooms lightly tossed in olive oil with salt and pepper. Be adventurous. Try this wine! Rating: 88.

Robert Whitley may be reached at whitonwine@aol.com.

© Copley News Service

Visit Copley News Service at www.copleynews.com.




AddThis Social Bookmark Button RSS Get RSS Feed for Robert Whitley Email updates Email me Robert Whitley updates Comments Comments
Originally Published on Monday June 23, 2008

Editors Picks - Lifestyle Columns
Think Pink: Breast Cancer Awareness Month
Sharon Mosley
Gene Can Affect Ability To Lose Weight, Study Says
Dr. David Lipschitz
First Pup
Matthew Margolis
See All
More Robert Whitley
Nov. `08
Su Mo Tu We Th Fr Sa
26 27 28 29 30 31 1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 1 2 3 4 5 6
View By Month
About the author Print friendly format Write the author Email This Article to a friend
All newspaper editors want to know what their readers like. If you would like to read this feature in your local newspaper, please do not hesitate to share your enthusiasm with your local newspaper editor.

 

Shop Creators Syndicate

 
Sunday, November 23, 2008 | 8:44 a.m.
About Creators | Privacy Policy | Contact Us | Editor's login | FAQ | En Español
Copyright © 2006 Creators.com. All Rights Reserved.
Web Development by JJCO